COVID-19 Updates
We are open! Stop by to create your own ice cream flavor or call ahead for pickup!
Judge's Choice Rollup Ice Cream |1272 Hill Rd NPickeringtonOH43147 | (614) 604-8609
Judge's Choice Rollup Ice Cream
1272 Hill Rd N
PickeringtonOH 43147
 (614) 604-8609
We Are Open!
(614) 604-8609

Now Offering Shakes and Flurries!

item imageCREATE YOUR OWN SHAKEVanilla, Strawberry, Hot Fudge, Caramel, Banana, Coca Powder, Peanut Butter, Oreo, Rose Syrup

Choose 2 mix’in’s or Toppings

Add Extra $0.70 | Small $3.49 | Medium $3.99 | Large $4.89
item imageCREATE YOUR OWN FLURRYVanilla, Strawberry, Hot Fudge, Caramel, Sea Salt, Banana, Coca Powder, Peanut Butter, Reese’s, Oreo, Rose Syrup, Cookie dough, Pecan, Brownie, Kitkat

Choose 2 mix’in’s or Toppings

Add Extra $0.70 | Small $3.99 | Medium $4.59 | Large $5.49


item image

Ice cream shop Pickerington, OH

When in Pickerington, OH, visit Judge's Choice Rollup Ice Cream! This Columbus suburb is home to our very own Thai sensation of rolled ice cream. Choose from a wide selection of signature ice cream rolls, or make your delicious creation. Our namesake dish has a unique twist on classic sundae recipes, which includes a nitro ice cream mixture with a fan or fruits, candies, and syrups to top it off. Call us today and stop in for a delicious cup of ice cream rolls. 


The Thai Sensation of Rolled Ice Cream

Our nitrogen ice cream ingredients are locally-sourced, and our rolled sundaes are crafted for you with love. You can create the creations served at Judge's Choice Rollup Ice Cream are unique to you, and each sundae comes with that visual appeal that'll feed your eyes. Choose from our menu of ice cream base flavors, and add in all of your usual favorite toppings as mixins. We will put then put all of your ice cream roll ingredients on a cold stone to be mixed, frozen, and rolled. Try one of our signature creations, create your own creation, or give one of our vegan options a try.

Our Menu Includes

  • Thai Rolled Ice Cream
  • Soy Free Ice Cream
  • Vegan Ice Cream
  • Gluten-Free Ice Cream
  • Lactose-Free Ice Cream
  • Sugar-Free Ice Cream
item imageGluten Free Rollup Ice Cream
item imageVegan Rollup Ice Cream
item imageSoy Free Rollup Ice Cream
item imageLactose Free Rollup Ice Cream

Visit Us

Get rollin' and head to Judge's Choice Rollup Ice Cream today! We are at 1272 Hill Rd N in Pickerington, OH, and you can call us at (614) 604-8609. We're excited to see what kind of ice cream rollup you create!

item image
Matcha Green Tea
STEP 2: CHOOSE 2 MIX-IN'SBananas, Strawberries, BlueBerries, Raspberries, Coconut, Almond, Oreo, M&M, Rainbow Sprinkles, Sweet Condensed Milk, KitKat, Peanut Butter Sauce/Brownie
STEP 3: CHOOSE 2 TOPPINGS FROM STEP 2 OR STEP 3Pocky Sticks/Green Tea Pocky Sticks/Mini Marshmallows/Whipped Cream/Cocoa Powder
"All products are made on equipment that comes contact with dairy ,nut,and wheat products”

Ask About Our Rolled Ice Cream

More Details:

More Details about Judge's Choice Rollup Ice Cream

Accepted Payment Methods:

  • Debit Card

Business Hours:

Business Hours:

Sunday 2:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Monday 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Tuesday 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Wednesday 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Thursday 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Friday 4:00 PM – 9:30 PM
Saturday 2:00 PM – 9:30 PM